|
Post by tintin on May 28, 2013 19:04:25 GMT 1
This is an absolutely marvellous book. It is very hard to believe that we are actually up to No.4 in the Timber Ridge series. It is fully up to the standard of the other three. Timber Ridge books are consistently almost as good as the sisters at their best, and I cannot praise more highly than that.
“Wish Upon a Horse” is basically an exciting story of show jumping and has more than enough action in, and outside, the ring to keep those who dream of success at this game happy. It is, however, also so much more.
To me the strong spine on which the great charm and effectiveness of the Timber Ridge stories rest is the well constructed central core of characters. Not only is each character individual, well drawn, interesting and believable, but they fit together as a group which facilitates the creation of a huge variety of convincing dramatic scenes and scenarios.
The start of the book is perhaps a little slower than the other three, but as this is a well developed series it allows those who are perhaps coming in new at book 4 to familiarise themselves. For us established fans it just builds up the sense of curiosity as to what they will do next and there is a certain comfort factor in just being a "fly on the wall" at Timber Ridge.
I will try hard not to give away too much, but as a lot of the thrills and charms of the book are in the situations that is not too easy.
Basically Kate has the money she made from her film riding and is wanting to buy a horse. Though this is quite a large amount of money she soon finds it does n’t go far.
Through a couple of scrapes she secures the (eventually) beautiful mare Tapestry. This is a lovely story and a lot happens before the two of them can stay together. Readers of the other stories will not be surprised where Tapestry came from, but there are still plenty of surprises about her. The romance with the film star continues as does the bickering with Angela the villain. There is a really good twist in the story with Angela which surprised me, which will probably surprise other readers even more. There is also a well drawn encounter with the darker side of show jumping.
Readers will be pleased that the distinctive humour of these books is still in place.
Timber Ridge is in many ways very contemporary (also very US) and I cannot vouch for the accuracy of the cultural and techno stuff, but it rang true to me. Also it did n’t alienate me (middle aged, British and techno phobe) and was totally natural and integral to the story.
Well worth reading.
Two personal notes.
Firstly, though I read this on Kindle I will be getting an actual paper back edition. I do not often buy books as artefacts, but this series is so nice I want a matching set. The art work is good. Even better the books have a good size and feeling for handling and the print size is great for reading.
Secondly, I LOVED Pardner. I could picture him – just my sort of horse! Although he only had a cameo role can he come back? The sort of horse who won’t let you down in field or stable. The ladies were very unkind about his looks and I think he should show them up. Perhaps his own book would be too much to ask?
|
|
|
Post by Claire on May 28, 2013 20:25:22 GMT 1
Great review tintin. I am sure Maggie will be chuffed with it. I must catch up with this series. So many books to read so little time...
|
|
|
Post by maggie on Jun 10, 2013 0:28:38 GMT 1
Maggie is VERY chuffed. She has only just found this!!!!!
My apologies for not responding sooner. I blame the good weather and an overdose of gardening and not enough time on the laptop.
Thank you Tintin and Claire, yet again, for your tremendous support and encouragement. You guys are totally great!
ps: Tintin ... I love Pardner, too. I hope to bring him back into the series soon.
|
|
|
Post by Claire on Jun 10, 2013 10:38:29 GMT 1
Thanks Maggie, well we only write what we think. If an author is great we will say so. I do think its important to promote good pony books and warn people about the dross thats out there.
|
|
|
Post by tintin on Jun 11, 2013 23:26:38 GMT 1
Totally echo Claire there. Although I always try to be constructive I would only give an honest review.
Maggie, your books are a tonic
|
|
|
Post by Claire on Jun 22, 2013 1:07:46 GMT 1
Just read this. After the excitement & novelty of the filming in book 3 this goes back to a very traditional story-line. Girl wants to buy a horse, falls in love with unsuitable rescue case, rescue case turns out to be pretty decent but then there is a danger of losing said horse. All brought up to date for the modern era with things like texting and facebook, etc. I like the fact that facebook causes a lot of trouble in the book, as it can in real life. Maggie really has a great touch in melding traditional plots and scenarios with all the modern stuff which today's kids relate to. And as Tintin says she does this without putting off the older generation - I think this is largely thru Kate who is a bit of a luddite compared to most teens and isn't as obsessed with facebook and the like as her contemporaries. She is quite an old fashioned girl in many ways and I think this appeals to the older generation, whereas Holly is the 'typical' teen. I am madly in love with Pardner! I'm glad to hear he will be reappearing again. However his brief cameo made me annoyed with the usually likeable Kate who decides she can't buy him cos he is not pretty: "But Kate couldn’t go through with it. No matter how good-natured this horse was, he’d always be an ugly horse and she’d probably end up hating him." Please Maggie don't let Kate turn into a horse snob! I do have a horror of them. Its OK for Angela to be snobby about horses' looks and breeding but Kate no! Talking of Angela, I've been hoping ever since book 1 when there was a bit of a connection between Kate and Angela and Kate realised that Angela was to be pitied, that Kate will somehow connect further with her enemy and somehow redeem her. There seems to be a step towards it in this book. Angela seems almost human a couple of times, altho reverts back to her old awful self. But I do feel sorry for her having such a gruesome mother and I hope by the end of the series she is allowed to become a nicer person. (BTW Maggie f you are reading this how is Marcia so much nicer than Angela. I can't remember if this has been explained in any of the books? Is it because Mrs Dean is pinning all her hopes of fame to her elder daughter so she virtually ignores the younger?) Tintin do you have any theories on this?
|
|
|
Post by maggie on Jun 22, 2013 16:04:28 GMT 1
I am madly in love with Pardner! I'm glad to hear he will be reappearing again. However his brief cameo made me annoyed with the usually likeable Kate who decides she can't buy him cos he is not pretty It was one small way of showing that Kate isn't always 'perfect.' Some readers have chided me, gently, for not giving her enough flaws. Please Maggie don't let Kate turn into a horse snob! Don't worry, I won't! (BTW Maggie f you are reading this how is Marcia so much nicer than Angela. I can't remember if this has been explained in any of the books? Is it because Mrs Dean is pinning all her hopes of fame to her elder daughter so she virtually ignores the younger?) Tintin do you have any theories on this? See book #5, Chasing Dreams!
|
|
|
Post by Claire on Jun 22, 2013 19:24:42 GMT 1
Thanks for answering my questions Maggie I have never thought Kate is without faults, she is a thoroughly nice person which is perhaps a bit unusual but she is by no means perfect. I think her main problem is self doubt and lack of confidence. Not surprising considering she hasn't had a normal childhood at all. Its poignant when you read she has never had a best friend before Holly. I just felt that despising a horse for its looks would be completely out of character for her. Pus I think her personality perfectly complements Holly's. I dont think you need to change them at all Maggie IMHO (for what its worth!) Looking forward to book 5, especially now I know there is more 'Angela stuff' in it. I know she is the 'baddie' but I can't help feeling sorry for her and intrigued by her. I have rattled through books 3 and 4 and am having a slight break with some adult reading before book 5.
|
|
|
Post by tintin on Jun 23, 2013 0:29:06 GMT 1
Well my theory was it was because she was the youngest.. BUT now I can't give anything away. Enjoy the next book! It's different again. The villainy is in the extra class.
As to Pardner, well Kate has at least been honest with herself, and it is to her credit she wants a horse she feels she can make a whole hearted committment to.
As a slight aside in looking for a model for Honey some ladies have laughed at me (in a nice way) and told me I like "mens' horses". I have never thought of horses as gendered in this way! To these ladies Pardner would definitely be a "man's horse". Although they would n't express it like that I sense Kate and Holly look at him in rather the same way
|
|
|
Post by Claire on Jun 23, 2013 11:23:36 GMT 1
As a slight aside in looking for a model for Honey some ladies have laughed at me (in a nice way) and told me I like "mens' horses". I have never thought of horses as gendered in this way! To these ladies Pardner would definitely be a "man's horse". Although they would n't express it like that I sense Kate and Holly look at him in rather the same way I don't really understand this. To me a horse is a horse, I like em all shapes and sizes, but then again I just don't get a lot of the 'girly' stuff in life. Do you mean pretty dainty horses are for girls and butch rugged horses for boys? Couldn't wait to find out what happened next - started on book 5!
|
|
|
Post by maggie on Jun 23, 2013 16:29:11 GMT 1
As a slight aside in looking for a model for Honey some ladies have laughed at me (in a nice way) and told me I like "mens' horses". I have never thought of horses as gendered in this way! To these ladies Pardner would definitely be a "man's horse". Although they would n't express it like that I sense Kate and Holly look at him in rather the same way I don't really understand this. To me a horse is a horse, I like em all shapes and sizes, but then again I just don't get a lot of the 'girly' stuff in life. Do you mean pretty dainty horses are for girls and butch rugged horses for boys? Couldn't wait to find out what happened next - started on book 5! LOL !!!!!!
|
|
|
Post by tintin on Jun 24, 2013 13:37:40 GMT 1
Well if I was choosing a horse for a lady the only real differences (to me) from choosing for a man would be a tendency to look at shorter horses (but only because most women are shorter than most men), good shoulder and above average ability at standing still when being mounted. The last two are only really important if the lady is to ride side saddle.
Ironically the prettiest, daintiest little horses I have ever seen were ridden by the Arab Legion who are very manly men. The horses themselves were hard as nails and could live on next to nothing compared to a big butch looking British heavy weight hunter.
|
|
|
Post by maggie on Jun 24, 2013 21:39:33 GMT 1
Ironically the prettiest, daintiest little horses I have ever seen were ridden by the Arab Legion who are very manly men. The horses themselves were hard as nails and could live on next to nothing compared to a big butch looking British heavy weight hunter. Great observation, tintin. Am tucking that away for future ponderings.
|
|
|
Post by susanb on Jun 24, 2013 23:06:28 GMT 1
off topic for this thread, but tintin, I think you might really enjoy John Richard Young's Don Revere and Raffy quartet....about a young man who needs convincing that an Arabian horse can do ranch work, but once he's convinced, he's all in. The books take in ranch work, reining and cutting and conclude with Raffy and Don training for the Olympic 3 day eventing. They can be beastly expensive and hard to find, but oddly enough the first book, Arabian Cow Pony, at the moment appears to have a few copies available at a reasonable price on abebooks. Link to Claire's page on Young: johnrichardyoung.ponymadbooklovers.co.uk/
|
|
|
Post by tintin on Jun 25, 2013 21:57:41 GMT 1
Susan thanks for the heads up on these - ideal books I think for both me and my Dad.
|
|
|
Post by tintin on Jun 25, 2013 22:21:37 GMT 1
Manly men with pretty dainty horses Attachments:
|
|
|
Post by tintin on Jun 25, 2013 22:23:37 GMT 1
Ladylike lady with butch rugged horse Attachments:
|
|